Skip to content

U.S. Chief Negotiator Pleads Insanity on Historical Emissions


(Cross-posted from )

In his first press briefing at the COP-15, Todd Stern, the U.S. Special Envoy on Climate Change, flatly rejected the notion of a “climate debt” that the United States owes to countries damaged by climate disruption. By rejecting “climate debt,” he nearly dismissed the entire climate justice perspective.

It’s as if Stern tried to plead insanity in front of an international, intergenerational jury. How would you vote on that jury? He argued the U.S. isn’t responsible for past emissions because we didn’t know what we were doing. We were ignorant at first, but we’ve been learning for several decades now (even though the EPA only announced its final endangerment finding earlier this week). We kept emitting as we learned. We’re still emitting.

The country with the far-and-away highest GDP in the world gained its wealth by burning enormous volumes of fossil fuels, leading to an unprecedented, global ecological crisis. Now, that country–the U.S.–appears willing to fix the climate and help others adapt to inevitable damages only as far as these actions are necessary to promote American security and global influence. For most activists here, this injustice is the motivating factor for their protest.

Todd Stern recognized the “need” for assistance to other countries, but the U.S. climate package for foreign assistance did not approach the levels justified by its world-record-holder status for cumulative greenhouse gas emissions. That’s because the delegation refuses to consider moral responsibility for damages caused to other countries. For instance, what will the U.S. owe when island nations are displaced from their land due to rising seas?  Or when the next tsunami hits the coasts on the Indian Ocean? The United States isn’t alone in denying these responsibilities, but it is the most egregious offender.

Sylvia Wachira of the African Youth Initiative on Climate Change (AYICC) delivered a moving speech today on climate injustice in the CMP plenary session. She was one of the only non-governmental speakers allowed to speak in front of all the assembled delegates. I encourage you to watch the webcast [skip to 1:42:00] or read the transcript below.

Thank you Mr. Chairman.

I am speaking as a member of the Pan-African Climate Justice Alliance and Climate Justice Now!

Africa stands on the frontline of climate change. It is a cruel irony indeed that a people who have lived for so long in harmony with nature are now suffering the disastrous effects of greenhouse gases emitted by developed countries.

For over two centuries the industrialized world became wealthy by drenching the atmosphere in carbon and plundering resources from every region of the world.

The current proposal and pledges by Annex I Parties are supposedly aimed at limiting global warming to 2 degrees. They will not, and 2 degrees is a death sentence for Africa.  According to the IPCC, Africa will warm by more than the average global level. 2 degrees globally means 3 or more degrees for my continent.

Such an increase in temperature would lead to widespread devastation.

It will lead to massive reduction in crop yields in some areas, cutting food outputs in half. More than 600 million people left without adequate water supplies. Our coastlines, villages and cattle will be ravaged. Literally millions of people will die.

The injustice does not stop here. Based on Annex I Parties current proposals and pledges, the 20% of people living in developed countries would consume over 60% of the Earth’s atmospheric space while the 80% who are poor will be consigned to live within the remaining 40%.  You are literally stealing from us the very sky over our heads.

A mere $10 billion is proposed under the Convention negotiations in so-called short-term financing, while the rich countries seek to appropriate from poor countries an atmospheric resource worth trillions. Your 10 billion will not be enough to buy our coffins.

We are expected to accept this deal. Worse still we are expected to celebrate this as success.

We will not.

This grab of our shared atmospheric resource is nothing less than climate colonialism.

Yesterday, African civil society marched alongside Parliamentarians from across the continent chanting: “Two degrees is suicide” and “One Africa, One Degree”.  You must all be absolutely clear: we will not die in silence.

[Watch for the second U.S. press briefing this afternoon at 2:30pm GMT+1. See the UNFCCC Webcast page.]

2 Comments leave one →
  1. Dr. Ross Taylor permalink
    12/11/09 7:10 am

    Update on non-warming in Copenhagen: As emergency AGW conference continues, it is perhaps ironic to study some weather information readily available on the internet. I apologize that the figures are not absolutely precise because they are taken from graphs at Anyone can check my calculations, which took about 20 minutes and were not taxpayer funded.

    In the last 28 years (as far as the online records go back), the highest December temperature in Copenhagen was 11 degrees C and that was back in 1983. Over these years, the average highest December temperature was around 7 C.

    First day of Copenhagen: a high of 7 C, exactly the same as the average high of the last 28 years and 4 degrees COOLER than the high of the last 28 years.

    Second day: a high of 7 C, the same.

    Third day: a high of 6 C, 5 degrees cooler than the December high of the last 28 years.

    Fourth day: a high of 6 C

    Can someone please point this out to the eminent and learned delegates?

  2. Jay Wellik--Dallas, TX permalink
    12/11/09 4:26 pm

    This is crazy. Maybe this is why Stern was never showcased at the preliminary meetings.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: